You want a good resale, close your eyes and go Buy GLI
Both cars have their on Pros & Cons, it depend what are your needs
You will drive on Bumpy/village roads mostly
Will have family with you most of time
Cheap Spare parts
For all above go for GLi
Mostly drive in City
Well carpeted roads
On motorways & highways
Want Driving Pleasure I.e more control at high speeds and good braking bettr accleration
Go for City
In the end it always depends on your need and Preferences.