Mukhtaran Mai - The Story

[Fuhrer_Hurricane]

i wonder why don't we accept that we are a flawy nation? men took away her respect and then they expect her to suicide...its like animal world where you have right to do everything just because you are born powerful (being a man) this mentality is weirdest thing on earth.

and theres nothing wrong if she got justice using NGO or US....since we denied her any justice or any chance of respectable life....she is a human and has as much right to live happily as anyone else has.......

now instead of getting pi55ed off on what she earned in the case its better to start over the fcuked up process of justice in our country

[Fuhrer_Hurricane]

@TrueEye
you are mentioning the number of rape cases in west....also mention the benefits and state assistance provided to the women who were victims and then see how pakistani society treats such victims...

why just one side of the picture?

[TrueEye]

you are late, as most of my replies have been deleted by some dear biased mod. Its just to piss off some guys who think that nothing happens in their part of the world, so relax man, i'm well aware of the facts.

[Haceeb]

all is well in the land of the pure..

[La010]

These guys should be hanged,No respect for woman.

[atta]

@ s90
No doubt she got special attention bt as i said earlier she didnt knew it b4 or do u think she planned all tht?? aftr gettin raped this thing came in her mind tht she shd do this n tht n thn she can visit US etc, i think this is all bcoz of NGOz, all women need justice not only sympathy, bt who will giv thm justice u??? or me??? v both cant do anything, v can jst sit here n can chat on all this, thts it huh n maximum v can blame our politicionz our lawz thts it or v can start abusing each othr wid rage thts all v can do

[s55]

@atta

No doubt she got special attention bt as i said earlier she didnt knew it b4 or do u think she planned all tht?? aftr gettin raped this thing came in her mind tht she shd do this n tht n thn she can visit US etc

Will you deny to accept the lottery money if you get lucky? though you never thought of it.

i think this is all bcoz of NGOz, all women need justice not only sympathy, but who will give them justice u??? or me??? v both cant do anything, v can just sit here n can chat on all this, thats it huh n maximum v can blame our politician our laws thats it or v can start abusing each othr wid rage thats all v can do

NGOs are just promoting there own business, they showed the world only one case and will get funds for hundreds. And we can do anything, its just that we are a sleeping nation, we dont like each other. We pull legs of each other. Men power is not utilized the way it was supposed to.

[atta]

^^^^tht wht em sayin tht NGOz highlited the case, definately no1 will deny lottery money bt she didnt hit the jackpot did she?? may b u can say tht coz u r not a woman, she got the money on the grave of her IZZAT, honour

[s55]

@atta
Do you expect from Pakistani women to come forward boldly and tell the world that she was raped? I dont think so. Pakistani women are naturally shy, they would like to kill themselves then going on air. I have no sympathy for this woman as she has shattered the image of those other women who have suffered hundred times more than this bold woman.
All this was not for justice but for the money.

[atta]

@ s55
so u mean tht women shd keep on doin suicides aftr gettin rape n shd not get those a$$.... in front of public, wow gd to know tht litterate ppl of pk thinks in this way, if they not feel ashamed in doin this thn y only woman??? y women hav to suffer??? yyyyyy?? y she shdnt try to punish the men??? wow gr8, women cant even walk on road u know y???? i myself saw this a few time in markts n on roadz n once this happend wid a frnd of mine whn v were on road a guy came n touched her back, wht 4???? wht the hell he got frm tht??? this all happen in marktz tooo y??? once v were in pace v were on escelator n a guy was goin downwards frm othr one n he touched her arm y??????? wht the hell is this now women cant even go out??? this is wht the educated ppl like u want????
dont mind on being harsh plz, sorry

[s55]

@atta
Justice is fine I said, but earning big money out of it is shame.

[s55]

@atta
Girls in big cities are responsible for the disgrace of their race. You know what I mean, now dont say that they have the right to live and whatever they want to do.

[Wahaj12]

@s55: bro, you're talking like a feudal...

in our culture, feudals justify rape as a form of punishment..

the story was shared to show the determination of a single woman...the NGO's came to know about it much much later, but to struggle to get to that point is what matters. 99.9% of rape cases don't even get reported, how can we expect justice if they r not reported?

if u r slapped on our face by someone, would u sit back because of the fear of news leaking out and causing shame, or fight for it?

and u r justifying women who commit suicide...instead of reporting....this case demonstrates that a single person can make a difference.

i m sorry, but such replies and comments make me sick to the core!

[XcellenceInXecution]

We Pakistanis have a very bad habit of pulling the legs of our fellow countrymen, in short feel sorry to see others happy and developing – learn, pll learn from the a$$'s around our borders the way they have develop themselves they do not fight within themselves but compete with each other.

Now if she is happy with her life ppl like @s55 blame her for what happened to her Cause she is living a better life.

s55: you mean that she got her self raped for this, this gives me a flash back to Mussaraff's Words at White House questioned by reporter Musshh said " If you want to earn money free visa to US/Canada get yourself rape " ---- that SOB gave an image to the world saying Pakistani Womens are like this.

And you are repeating the same thing - Feel sorry for you.

[atta]

@ s55
ya i know bt not all girls r same the girls wid me r alwayz wid dupatta on their heads so y this happen to thm too???
i agree to ur point, bt the point is who can deny money??? whn govrnmnt giv money to those whose sons, husbands .... die in accidents or suicide attacks do they deny the money???

[Wahaj12]

the money is given to fight her case...and for community service..

most people don't go to courts because of moneatary problmes..

[s55]

@XcellenceInXecution and @Wahaj12
President was absolutely right. I never said dont raise your voice for justice, but dont earn in the name. What does millions of rupees have to do with living a better life for a rural woman? only makhdoum amin faheem gave her 50-70 lac (couldnt remember the exact amount) leave other donation aside, she is millionair I suppose or atleast that NGO. How will you justify that?
I would have been feeling proud on her if she had fight for issue and not to cash her sufferings.
Its similar to what we see on roads, people begging in the name of their children.

[Qaisrani]

i just say that this case was not 100 o/o true.
it was a political case and some people and countries have there own interest thats why mukhtiaran mai become famous and this case become very importent. i have many things in my mind . i also know many hidden trouth becaoz that days i was at importent post.
so it is my request , please closed this discusion.

[s55]

@atta

whn govrnmnt giv money to those whose sons, husbands .... die in accidents or suicide attacks do they deny the money???

Consider a son or father who is the only earner and hope for his family dies in an accident, his family deserves to get some financial help though its not the replacement of their damage.
Dont mix that with this case, they are two entirely different scenarios.

[s55]

jaldi jaldi discussion karo mujhe dune bashing par jaana hai