I would not recommend any type, they are a pain. Even when fully secure they make noise at highway speeds. When they are lose they will make tik tik noise all the time. They always get lose due to washing of cars. Lastly when you want to remove them that glue doesnt go easily.
If you want to smoke and its raining outside that is the only time they are useful at least to me. I have stopped applying them on.
having said that, if you really want airpress use clips and double tape both. do not buy opaque cheap plastic ones, get transparent shade which loot a bit aerodynamic. will cost you three thousand at most.