as per my experience I have a good time with Maintenance free batteries,I am using maintenace free batteries for more than 4 and half years without any problem even in colder weather
& when you talk about non maintenace free batteries, then I have used almost all of above mentioned batteries but in my opinion according to my experience ,EXIDE is best ( I think but i am not sure that nowadays they are giving 6 months warranty /guarantee) but I used same EXIDE battery for 2 years 2 months without any problem