Alsvin vs Saga vs City (2017 to 2020)

[mukarrum.s90]

Hi, I want to buy a car and I am confused between three options proton saga(Ace), city auto(2017 to 2020) or alsvin(comfort or Lumiere).

I need opinions based on comfort, driving experience, build quality and cabin noise. Please neglect parts availability when sharing your opinion also fuel avg is not a major concern for me because on working days I alternatively go to the office which is the major chunk of my traveling and for that I use my motorcycle and I plan to the same even after buying a car due to traffic issues of Karachi.

I know saga is of a different category but my concern is the drive quality not the size of the cabin. Also I will be buying low mileage car therefore delivery delay is not a concern for me

[dr.salmanawan]

Looking at your requorements, my opinion is that Lumiere will be best suited for you

[sargodhiyan101]

I would propose Alsvin Comfort, it misses out on the Sunroof and eco idle. Saga is a NoGo the car is a Failure bcs of high fuel consumption. City has really hard suspension but the drive quality is really good and interior looks as well but I would prefer a new Car over an old one so Alsvin.