you will have to decide what matters more, If you want a car that retains or at times increases its value go for a toyota corolla, parts are also cheaper and readily available and it is comfortable enough.
On the other hand Premio is even more comfortable than a corolla, has similar fuel efficiency but does not retain its value as well as a corolla does.
A more latest model vehicle is much better than a used and old model. This all depends on your budget and if you can get a new or latest model.