as you described the condition of both the cars about the same ... umm..if i were you, i would have gone for the latest model (2008) . kyon k phir bhi, agar condition dono ki 19/20 hai to at least model to new hai , kuchh cheezain to phir bhi behtar hon gi.
however, i would seriously advise you to be prepared to spend 20-30k more on the car to bring it into your required condition or otherwise, increase your budget and find another good car if you don't want to go to workshops every other week.