Toyota Carolla Gli Automatic (2015) vs Toyota Vitz F 1.0 (2015)

[coachbef]

Which car is the best buy in the 16 Lac budget (possibility of stretching the budget to 20 Lac with a car loan)? Given the following priorities:

Priorities: (i) Overall Build Quality. (ii) Overall Comfort (iii) Maintenance Cost (iv) Travel within Lahore.
Following are NOT my priorities (i) power (ii) mileage

(i) Toyota Carolla Gli Automatic with Immobilizer key(probably 2016) (USED)
(ii) Toyota Vitz F 1.0 (2015) Auction Grade 4.0 or higher (Freshly Imported)

P.S. Planning to keep the car for a good 15-20 years.

[hayatumer82]

corolla without a doubt....satisfies all points...

[ahmad_ali_asghar]

Is carolla GLi build quality superior to a vitz?

[sayedgulhassan]

Corolla without any doubt you can get 2016 immobilizer gli in 20lacs

[coachbef]

The Vitz listed above can be bought in 16.5 lacs (inclusive of registration+taxes) and i can save 3.5 lacs. Is carolla gli worth the extra 3.5 lacs?

[nawan885]

A good grade and low mileage vitz is trouble free for next 5 years. At least I have for last 4 years. It is not under power for plain terrains. Only advantage of gli is local manufacturing and big boot... and now dobt gli is also reliable car...zero .meter

[sayedgulhassan]

It depends on your needs whether you need hatch back or sedan... Where would you most be driving? Which type of road? How much will be your daily drive?
Corolla is durable car and is comfortable... My cousin owns 2012 vitz but corolla is far better in comfort as per my observations his daily drive is about 80kms and he doesnt take his car to office, uses pick and drop service.

[coachbef]

I slightly prefer hatchbacks only because of the rush. Drive is Mostly within the city. Even city Roads are mostly bumpy. Daily drive is 25 Km.

Which car is cheaper to maintain and has cheaper spare parts in case it gets into an accident?

[basitali87]

Bro, priority wise:
Corolla'
Vitz'
And at the Last:
Cultus AGS.

[basitali87]

Bro, Sedan can not, and never be compared with a hatchback, however, all depends on your priorities.
If you wanna go for hatchback, go for Vitz, otherwise if Sedan; then Corolla without any doubt.

Sedan will always and definitely be expensive than a hatchback, and the drive comfort of a Sedan is far better and Superior than a hatchback (keeping all other factors same).

Toyota Toyota hai, Cheap Maintenance, mazbuuti, reliability aur Paidaari mein isay koi beat nai karta!

[usman_arooq2]

I'd say corolla's worth extra 3.5 lac.

[haseeb.basharat]

If mostly city drive and you prefer smaller car than go for city instead. Although I would advice you to go for corolla, but your main concern is to drive in city.

[nifiii]

2015 Corolla does not have an immobilizer. Stay away from it.

[sayedgulhassan]

Vitz parts are expensive and difficult to trace out in the market... Corolla maintenance is cheap and its a rough and tough car while vitz and other japanese cars are fragile and our mechanics are not good enough for these cars. Btw which car were you using before?

[sayedgulhassan]

I think in 20 lacs he can easily get a 2016 preFL GLI auto which has immobilizer

[sayedgulhassan]

Bhai he needs comfort and there is no comparison btw corolla and city comfort level.

[coachbef]

I have been using dad's mehran.
So, Vitz is fragile?

[coachbef]

Yes Carolla takes the cake when it comes to comfort when comparred with City.

[abid110]

buy a 2015 corolla - have it comprehensively insured to be saved from thefts/snatching as its a very hot cake - and sell it after 2 years still in a good profit. you will enjoy every bit of it and totally tension free thing...

[sayedgulhassan]

He can get a clean 2016 GLI AUTO with company immobilizer in 20 lacs even more cheaper if in karachi.