Alto VXR 2019 vs Used Cultus VXR (New Shape 2017)

[mirfan.khalid]

I am looking for a car under 13 Lac PKR. I have to travel 100 to 150 KM on highway daily. So what do you recommend considering economy & reliability & durability??
1. Alto VXR 2019
2. Used Cultus VXR (New Shape 2017)
3. Used WagonR
4. JDM Japanese Car

[sleeper]

Cultus the way to go
Bigger engine
Stable than WagonR
Economy reliability almost same for top 3
Durability i think Cultus better
No JDMs

[yrmd26]

Go for newer generation cultus. Similar economy as an alto 660 on highways but with way better stability and performance.

[saadtiger412]

Cultus is better option. It has better shape and has better fuel economy

[saad.ikram.5688]

For your requirement Cultus VXR seems to be the best option.
Low maintenance cost.
Decent Engine size
Decent Space
Great mileage

[saqibhassan95]

As all said, cultus vxr will be best for you

[mirfan.khalid]

Would you please share the kmpl with AC on highway of both Cultus & Alto?

[mirfan.khalid]

Dear, its hard to believe that economy is same for 3, alto, cultus & wagonR. Would you please elaborate?

[aliaamir0335]

cultus all the way

[sleeper]

By economy you mean fuel avg right?

If so, then as per many members and owners here, they are getting 17-20 km/ltr in their altos and cultuses....wagonR may be slightly low like in 14-17 range but i have taken all the 3 cars as a whole..

U cant compare these cars on their exact fuel avg figures because company claims something and owners get other...the owners are themselves so much mixed like for eg my cousin with heavy foot was getting max 11 on his WagonR, next month with same car and light foot i got round 15.

This is why i have taken all 3 in same bracket
U see both cultus and WagonR have same engine, while its pretty obvious that people with alto are getting atleast 15plus avgs

[saqibhassan95]

Considering fuel avg, I will rank like this
In same city conditions with ac
1-alto, around 19-20
2- cultus around 16-17
3-wagonr around 12-13
Anyone can disagree
Overall cultus is a sweetspot for you
On long, at 110-120 km/h
1- alto around 22-23
2- cultus around 20-21
3- wagonr around 16-18

[anon35615524]

Used Cultus VXR (New Shape 2017)

Go for it!

[saqibhassan95]

Considering wagonr fuel average
Some reviews by owners

In mild traffic urban driving, wagon r doesnt give more than 12-13 with ac. It gets worse with congested traffic

Personal experience & comparison of Wagon R VXL 2019 with Alto VXL AGS 2020

Fuel economy Swift never gave me more than 10kmpl with ac on no matter what I did. However, it might have given better average had I tried 0w20 oil in it. I only had chance of single oil change on my swift and I poured 5w40. Wagon r too was not giving more than 12 kmpl with ac on but ever since I switched to 0w20 oil, the fuel economy of wagon r has improved slightly. Alto definitely takes lead in this department. Even with my heavy foot driving, alto doesnt give less than 16-17 kmpl with AC. With moderate foot driving, it easily gives 20-22 kmpl.

Personal experience & comparison of Wagon R VXL 2019 with Alto VXL AGS 2020

WagonRCons:Fuel Avg is bad. 12-13.5 in summers / 14-14.5 in winters (60 km daily journey)

Personal experience & comparison of Wagon R VXL 2019 with Alto VXL AGS 2020

Fuel average is a real turn off, I don't know how do people manage 16kmpl on this car ?

Personal experience & comparison of Wagon R VXL 2019 with Alto VXL AGS 2020

Fuel Average

As discussed in earlier comments, Wagon R used to give an average of 10.5 - 11.5 kmpl in city driving with AC and 12.5 to 13.5 kmpl with AC off and applying hypermiling techniques where applicable.

[scholar.center]

For alto 2019 vxr. 23.3 kmpl with ac on long route with light foot.
No idea about new cultus....

[mirfan.khalid]

Thanks for the guidance. Does anyone have idea about Cultus AGS kmpl in city & long? What will be the price of Cultus AGS 2018 now a days??

[saqibhassan95]

Cultus ags average is same as manual vxl
In city traffic with ac 16-17 without ac upto 18-19
On long at 120km/h, 22-23 approx
Regarding Price of a specific car, it depends upon condition and odo.

[mirfan.khalid]

I want to get an idea about Price range of Cultus AGS 2018. Not asking for a specific car. Is there anyone who buy it recently?