Depends, if power wise, no. Economy wise, yes, noise wise, yes as I am used to quieter vehicles. If compared to speed manuals, noise wise, not much difference. Speeds above 150, well if you compare it with the 1.3, you won't miss it, with the cvt, you will.
As for resale, one can never be too sure, but for the next 2 years, gli, then 1.6, followed but cvt