Hi,
Before providing you with my opinion, I would like to know that your new car will be driven in what sort of area i.e. rural / urban / sub urban?
Because , as an old driver, I would give you my best opinion based upon my experiences.
If you're going to drive in rural / countryside areas, then go for Toyota.
If you're going to drive in urban / sub urban areas, then go for Honda.
Toyota's suspension has more tendency to cope up with the rural areas of our country, whereas Honda's are best in the urban areas.
Also, not sure if you'll be looking at MPG or not.
At the end of the day, it's your call 
Best of luck for your future ride!