Does the absence of VSC in PKDM Hilux Revo spell trouble for consumers?

dsc05420

On 6th December 2016, Toyota Indus introduced the highly anticipated Hilux Revo, dubbed as the King of Pakistan in many circles; the new vehicle was aimed to take the market by storm. The company, as per the stats released by PAMA, have sold 2,976 units of Toyota Hilux from Jan-May 2017, 42.6% increase for Hilux from the same period of last year. Add in the wait time of six to seven months and a premium of five to six lac, the Hilux Revo can be safely called a successful vehicle. So you might be wondering, what seems to be the issue? The answer, in essence, lies in the safety features or lack of thereof in this vehicle. Yes, Toyota Indus is offering Anti-lock Brake System (ABS), Electronic Brake Distribution (EBD) and Brake Assist (BA) but what about the Vehicle Stability Control (VSC), which is being considered as a paramount safety feature to prevent sideways skidding in an event of sudden manoeuvring/braking at high-speeds to avoid an obstacle. Many of you might be wondering isn’t ABS, Traction Control or EBD supposed to achieve the same results? Technically speaking, the answer is no. Because all these safety electronics overlap so much that understanding them from cursory reading isn’t enough. The good news is that you don’t have to understand it to benefit from it; the bad news is that a lot of cars don’t come with them in Pakistan. So, following is my take on explaining what ABS, Traction Control, EBD, VSC and Brake Assist.

  • Vehicle Stability Control – A fully computerized electronic system that applies brakes to individual tyres and reduces engine power to ensure that drivers maintain control of their vehicles. In short, ESC can be described as anti-skid control, and it primarily corrects understeer and oversteer. Also known as Electric Stability Control (ESC) and Vehicle Stability Assist (VSA) and a myriad of other names, this system was first introduced by Mercedes in 1990 and has proven to drastically lower fatal automobile accidents. The main components of a VSC system are wheel speed sensors, a control module, a steering angle sensor, a yaw rate sensor, an accelerometer, and the hydraulic modulator. Additionally, the hydraulic modulator (master cylinder) for both VSC and ABS are same, meaning that a VSC system only requires an additional yaw sensor accelerometer and steering angle sensor to a standard ABS system. So how does it work? To limit the scope of this article I won’t be explaining how the system works but to for a better (visual) understanding, you can watch the attached video

  •  Anti-lock Braking System – Possibly one of the most widely tested technology at this point. So what does it do? Conventional brakes lock up when pressed suddenly and hard, which increases the stopping distance and makes the driver lose control of the car. The ABS sensors detect this lock-up and release-apply brakes with very short intervals to erode out the possibility of any lock-up. Cycling the brakes quickly between locking and just short of locking is a very good approximation to threshold braking. A standard Anti-lock Braking System uses four wheel speed sensors, a hydraulic pump, four hydraulic valves (assuming it is a 4 channel setup), and a controller. Here is a visual demo of how ABS works:

  • Traction Control – To counteract the concept of open differential (the wheel with the least traction receiving the most power), traction control system is used to monitor wheel speed using ABS wheel speed sensors. If a wheel is slipping, TC reduces engine power to help the wheel regain its traction. Additionally, the traction control can also apply brakes to the slipping wheel, which transfers power to other wheel(s), depending on surface conditions. Here is a visual demo of how Traction Control works:

  • Brake Assist – An active safety feature designed to help drivers to stop quickly during an episode of emergency braking. The ECU compares each instance of braking the pre-set values. If the driver pushes the brake paddle harsh and fast enough to surpass this pre-set values, the ECU will then engage the brake to assist feature. Here is a visual demo of how Brake Assist works:

  • Electronic Brake Force Distribution – To maximize the brake force, this system actively combats fishtailing by balancing brake force applied to each wheel. For example, slamming on the brakes pushes the weight of the vehicle forward. When this happens the rear wheels may suffer a decrease in traction, which could potentially result in the rear wheels to spin or lock up. Thus, the chances of fishtailing can increase exponentially. This system balances out the brake force with respect to the weight distribution of the vehicle. The end result ensures prevents wheel lockage by reducing brake force to spinning wheels, but can also allocate more brake force to wheels that it detects are already braking effectively. Here is a visual demo of how EBD system works:

What & how important is Moose test?
Now that we have discussed the application of safety systems, it is now time to come back to the topic at hand. The lack of VSA means PKDM Toyota Hilux Revo is prone to losing control on evasive maneuvers. The alarming thing is that the vehicle in question comes standard with VSA across many countries including Thailand, America etc and yet it failed to pass the Moose Test.
Here is the video of first Moose Test of Hilux Revo conducted by Teknikens Värld:

 

The Moose Test is an evasive maneuver test designed to determine how well a certain vehicle evades a suddenly appearing obstacle. And by the looks of it, Hilux Revo failed this test. Toyota, however, revised their VSA system to improve it, here is the second video of their test.

The vehicle did pass this Moose Test, but the irony of the absence of VSA in PKDM Hilux remains glaring. 4×4 vehicles have a higher center of gravity and thus are more likely to flip over in any fast evasive maneuvering due to a high center of gravity and less aerodynamic physical appearance. Thus, full fledge 4×4 vehicles are relatively expensive because of the gadgetry, safety systems and overall cost of production is higher than sedans or two wheel drive vehicles. As pointed out earlier, Toyota Hilux has a wait time of 6-7 months, a premium of 6-7 lac and an ex-factory price of 4,299,000 rupees and still miss out on a fundamental feature like Vehicle Stability Control is disappointing, to say the least. It goes on to show how far behind Pakistani Automotive Industry is then a lot of countries across the world and immediate neighborhood. This trend is not just limited to Hilux Revo, any observant can list down a lot of vehicles that are being sold in Pakistan, which are globally obsolete or lack the most basic of safety equipment such as airbags etc. The point of this article is not to demean anyone, rather it is aimed to highlight the glaring fact of the options that Pakistanis receive for the money they spend on commodities like vehicles. The need for a local automotive standard authority is required more than ever in this day & age to design, strengthen and uphold driver and passenger safety standards in Pakistan. Last but not the least, I will leave you with a question; If the (International) variant of Hilux Revo equipped with VSC fails to complete the Moose Test on its first try then what hope does the PKDM Hilux Revo has to pass this test?

Hanan is an avid auto enthusiast with a flair for writing and playing games. He loves traveling, deciphering political maneuvering and exploring the realms of coding & graphic designing.

Notable Replies

  1. aa78 says:

    Good article highlighting consumer/driver safety issues. Well done!

  2. how many cars do you see in Pakistan that follow any safety standard even from the 1950s???

    Most customers of this truck will not like to see their work/farm truck be a computer on wheels.

Post a Comment

Participants

Top