Parallel vs. Series Hybrids – All Things You Need to Know

1 4,469

Hybrids are everywhere these days, and for a good reason—fuel prices in Pakistan are through the roof, and everyone’s looking to save money. However, there are two main types of hybrid cars: parallel hybrids and series hybrids. Don’t worry; it’s not as complicated as it sounds. Let’s break it down in simple terms and figure out which one makes more sense for you in Pakistan.

1-1 Table Comparison

Here’s the quick comparison in the table to save you time

Aspect Parallel Hybrid Series Hybrid
Working Mechanism Both the internal combustion engine (ICE) and the electric motor directly drive the wheels. The ICE acts solely as a generator to charge the battery, and only the electric motor drives the wheels.
Power Distribution Power is split between the ICE and the electric motor, with both working together or independently based on driving conditions. The electric motor provides all the power to the wheels, while the ICE operates only to charge the battery.
Efficiency More efficient at higher speeds and long highway commutes due to the contribution of the ICE. Best suited for urban, stop-and-go traffic where the electric motor handles most of the load.
Fuel Economy Offers balanced fuel efficiency in mixed driving conditions. Superior fuel economy in heavy traffic and low-speed driving.
Performance Provides smoother transitions between electric and engine power, making it versatile. Offers instant torque due to the electric motor, but performance may decline at higher speeds.
Battery Usage Relies moderately on the battery, reducing the frequency of charging cycles. Relies heavily on the battery, increasing dependency on its charge level and health.
Maintenance Easier to maintain due to simpler mechanics and widespread familiarity among Pakistani mechanics. Requires specialized expertise, making maintenance more expensive and less accessible in Pakistan.
Spare Parts Availability Spare parts for popular parallel hybrid models (e.g., Toyota Prius) are readily available in the local market. Spare parts for series hybrids are less common and may need to be imported, increasing costs.
Cost Generally more affordable, with a lower upfront cost compared to series hybrids. Higher upfront cost due to advanced electric motor reliance and battery technology.

What’s a Parallel Hybrid?

Parallel Hybrid Configuration - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics

In a parallel hybrid system, the internal combustion engine (ICE) and the electric motor work together to power the vehicle’s wheels. Both the ICE and the motor are mechanically connected to the drivetrain, allowing them to operate independently or in tandem. In simple words, when you’re in the city or driving slowly in traffic, the electric motor takes over, saving you fuel. But when you hit the highway or need some extra power (like climbing hills), or at the high speeds like above 60 Km/h, the engine kicks in.

Take the Toyota Aqua, for example. It’s a favorite in Pakistan. The Aqua has a 1.5L engine and an electric motor that work together to give you killer mileage—usually around 20 to 24 km/l in cities. Then there’s the Toyota Prius, which is bigger and fancier. It has an 1.8L engine and still manages to give you around 18 to 22 km/l. Both cars are easy to maintain because Toyota’s hybrids have been around for ages here. And if you ever need to sell, you’re in luck—Aqua and Prius have some of the best resale values out there. Other HEV cars like the Vezel and Grace also provide very graceful mileage. 

What’s a Series Hybrid?

Series Hybrid Vehicle | Download Scientific Diagram

On the other hand, series hybrid systems operate differently. In this setup, the ICE is not directly connected to the wheels. Instead, it functions as a generator to produce electricity for the battery, which in turn powers the electric motor that drives the wheels. This arrangement ensures that the ICE runs at its most efficient RPM, reducing fuel consumption. While series hybrids excel in stop-and-go traffic due to their electric motor’s instant torque and reduced ICE usage, they are less common in Pakistan. This is mainly due to their higher initial cost and limited availability of parts and maintenance expertise in the local market.

A good example of this is the Nissan Note e-Power. It’s got a small 1.2L engine, but don’t let that fool you. The engine’s only job is to generate electricity, so the car feels super smooth and gives you amazing mileage, often over 20 km/l in city traffic. The downside? Energy loss. Since the power has to be converted from fuel to electricity, series hybrid cars aren’t as efficient as parallel hybrids like Aqua.

Which One’s Better for Pakistan?

When it comes to suitability for Pakistan’s conditions, parallel hybrids generally have the edge. The driving conditions in Pakistan often include frequent long-distance commutes on highways, which favor the dual power delivery of parallel hybrids. Additionally, parallel hybrids tend to have better resale value because of their established presence in the market and a larger pool of potential buyers. Resale is a critical factor for many Pakistani car buyers, and models like the Toyota Prius have proven to retain their value over time.

From a cost perspective, parallel hybrids are more economical in the Pakistani market. Their simpler mechanical design, compared to series hybrids, makes them easier to maintain. Spare parts for popular parallel hybrid models are readily available, and mechanics are generally familiar with their systems. In contrast, series hybrids may require specialized service expertise, which can be both expensive and difficult to find locally.

Let us know what you think which HEV system is better?

 

Google App Store App Store
1 Comment
  1. Ali Khan says

    The “Maintenance” part of the graph shown above might hold true from a Pakistani perspective but over all the Series hybrid is the more simpler design.

    Compared to parallel hybrids, the mechanical transmission between the engine and wheels is discarded, thus making the series hybrid a simpler design; even from a maintenance stand-point.

    Also, just like plug in hybrids, series hybrids can also be charged by external sources by plugin them into a power outlet.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.